Is Boris Safe?
A little over a week ago, Boris Johnson narrowly survived a vote of no confidence (59% vs 41%). The fact that Sir Graham Brady received 54 letters from Tory MPs wasn’t a great surprise – an increasing number of disgruntled back benchers have voiced their concerns about their leader and the need for change. Nevertheless, timing was always uncertain and consequently, I for one, was slightly surprised that we didn’t see more in the way of market reaction (either in FX or rates). Throughout Monday’s session, GBPUSD traded between 1.25 and 1.26 (with a slightly bid tone) while the two-year swap rate was steady between 248bps and 255bps.
The lack of market volatility was likely the result of three factors:
1. As already mentioned, the fact that the vote of no confidence came, probably wasn’t a massive surprise.
2. Even though a vote was called, the probability of Boris losing was relatively low.
3. Had the vote gone against the PM, it wouldn’t necessarily have resulted in a significant change. Assuming it didn’t trigger a general election, another Tory leader probably wouldn’t result in a dramatic change in policy. In fact, even under Labour leadership, I’d question how much change we’d see. Starmer’s centrist policies are a far cry from those that we might have seen from a Corbyn led government.
All that taken into consideration, I was still a little surprised sterling fared as well as it did. Maybe there was another factor at play – a large corporate bid for example?
Either way, the question we find ourselves asking now, is how safe is Boris and what happens if we get a change in leadership in the months ahead?
Theoretically, MPs are unable to call another Vote of No Confidence for another 12 months. However, rebels are already talking about how they could force another vote on Boris Johnson’s future and there is huge pressure on Sir Graham Brady to change the rules.
Moreover, if we look back at the last four leadership challenges, all resulted in a change of leader shortly after. Most recently, Theresa May won by a greater margin compared to Boris but was forced to resign six months later. The point being that once a PM begins to lose support of the party (and then public) it becomes very difficult to stop the rot.
Nevertheless, Boris has shown remarkable resilience during his tenure so far and for what it’s worth, the betting markets are suggesting a 27% probability of him leaving his post before the end of 2022, a 31% chance of his departure during 2023 and 42% on him remaining in office into 2024.
What does it mean for the outlook for sterling?
Intuitively, it feels highly unlikely that any sort of political uncertainty could be a positive for the pound. So, the question is, how negative could it be? In part, the answer will be dependent on what a change entails. Another Tory leader seems unlikely to be game changer. It may help unite the party in the short term but ultimately, it seems unlikely that we’ll see a dramatic shift in policy. A general election resulting in a change in government would likely be more negative, but as highlighted above, a Starmer led Labour Government is a far cry from how things might have looked under his predecessor.
For now, the greater determinant of sterling’s fate is the outlook for monetary policy and inflation relative to its peers. Given the Bank of England’s independence, a change in government shouldn’t really impact the outlook for monetary policy unless of course, it results in a significant change in fiscal policy.
Instead, the challenge facing the central bank is whether to risk tipping the economy into recession in an attempt to prevent prices spiralling further out of control. Yesterday’s GDP print showed the UK economy contracting 0.3% in April (vs expectations of +0.1%) with declines in services, construction and both manufacturing and industrial production. However, with headline inflation currently running at 9% (and expected to rise above 10% in the months ahead) there appears little scope for the MPC to take their foot off the gas when it comes to tightening monetary policy. The fact that real rates (adjusted for inflation) remain lower in the UK than they do for either the US or EU, doesn’t bode well for sterling.
A final point to note and a particularly important factor influencing sterling in the short term is the impact of risk sentiment. History tells us that sterling has a tendency to under-perform when markets are in ‘risk-off’ mode so with the S&P 500 now officially in bear market territory (i.e. 20% below its recent peak) there is a risk that sterling remains under pressure in the near term, particularly against the safe haven dollar.